This blog has been created to document my journey in reading "We Can't Teach What We Don't Know" by Gary Howard. It is my hope that while reading it, it will aid my development into a culturally competent teacher. I will be reading a section each week, explaining the content, responding to it, and applying it to things I may encounter in my future classroom.

"Can't Teach" is about the issues that come with diversity and how we can become more aware of our role as educators, especially since classrooms are becoming more diverse, and teaching is a predominantly White profession.

I decided to read this book because the title struck me as different. It's a posture towards diversity that I'm not familiar with. I also beleive the title to imply that the teacher is incapable of teaching unless they know everything. The journey of understanding begins now...

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

Unfinished Work and Conclusion

Teaching is not simply a job, nor can the work that educators do be defined as simple. What I have learned from Howard can be summed up in a small portion of his final chapter: 

"Whiteness is at best a dissonant identity. To be aware of one's Whiteness is to be in conflict, at least to some degree, with the social marker of race that we carry (p. 137)." And maybe that is the most of what I can ask of myself: awareness and flexibility to grow. It is an elaborate journey, full of many complexities, and I have a responsibility to be a teacher for social justice for change. Howard believes, and I agree that there is a responsibility that comes with teaching. White teachers have an opportunity to shift perceptions of race, dominance and discrimination. 

Though I feel impassioned and inspired to begin this intentional journey, I still carry the burden of what this response actually looks like in the classroom. For people from other races and cultures to White people, what do we need from each other to create spaces of trust and understanding that will help us communicate and grow in this way? Where is there room for this conversation in groups of teachers and in schools? 

It is my hope and goal to dive head in to the journey of becoming an educator for social justice. It is my passion. I want to teach students because I am as passionately a social rights activist as I am a lover and facilitator of learning. As I research, I have already come across a group in Chicago called Teachers for Social Justice and I will continue to pursue information that lets me make the biggest impact on a diverse group of students as possible. 

Monday, November 28, 2011

Multicultural Growth

“Those of us who have benefited from the history of White privilege do not have to perpetuate it into the next generation (p. 118).” 
I wanted to start off this post with a quote to remind my readers and myself that though discussing tough issues like racism, White identity, and dominance. We do these things because it’s the necessary foundation for a strong step forward. But the ultimate goal is hope, change and reform. It is in the hands of educators, and White educators have a pivotal role in this process.
The healing begins in schools because education has been a part of the social institutions that act as systems of privilege that are reinforced by power. It seems to me that sometimes education can favor certain groups over others. 
The main point of this section from the text is that the concept of social dominance and the achievement gap in education are related in two basic ways: the assumption of rightness and the luxury of ignorance. 
The assumption of rightness carries over into education because teachers often assume that a student’s school failures are the fault of the student or their family/environmental circumstances and not the school. When we assume that we are right, we assume that we know exactly what way is the best for each student. Howard shares stories where students of other races were held back, or nearly forced to join special education programs, even though they did very well in advanced classrooms. I think that it’s important to remember that we as educators sometimes need to get outside of our own minds and assume that we might need help instead. 
The second thing that Howard warns us against is the luxury of ignorance. This can be compared to what I’ve experienced as the “missionary mentality.” We run into it in education. It can be described is a teacher who walks into a classroom thinking that they are a privileged individual who can save the poor/disadvantaged “other.” This is a negative and wounding mentality that I have seen in the classroom. Students pick up on the teacher’s attitudes towards them and oftentimes react poorly or play out stereotypes. 
I must remember that change begins with me, because a student will know if I beleive in them, and worse, they will know if I don’t.

Sunday, November 27, 2011

Dominance, Identity and Change

This portion of the text is all about dominance and the assumption of rightness. The issue begins with realizing the fact that since the days of Columbus and the treatment of American Indians, we have been a part of culture that promotes superiority. Howard shares an image that I found to be helpful in understanding the relationship between White people and racism. 

“Racism for Whites has been like a crazy uncle who has been locked away for generations in the hidden attic of our collective social reality. This old relative has been part of the family for a long time. Everyone know’s he’s living with us, because we bring him food and water occasionally, but nobody wants to take him out in public. He is an embarrassment and a pain to deal with, yet our little family secret is that he is rich and the rest of  us are living, either consciously or unconsciously, off the wealth and power he accumulated in his heyday (Howard, p. 56).” 

This image gives me ownership of racism, which I beleive is the most important step. Whether I am conscious of it or not, racism is a part of my past and my history and the mentality receives “nourishment” from me every once and a while. I hate the poison that runs through my veins. I know that the nights that I waitress and encounter people of other races that fulfill stereotypes that are somehow engrained in my paradigm. This for me is the root of my problem. 

I know the negative damage of a perception like the (incredibly dated) “melting pot” idea that urged immigrants to abandon all possible cultural identifiers and blend into “White America.” The melting pot theory was something discussed and disclaimed for me in 8th grade by a good teacher. The notion of “colorblindness” is also a negative mentality where people state that they don’t see people’s color, believing that declaring to be “colorblind”  means declaring that all people are equal. I work hard to keep that mentality out of my classroom experiences. 

My remaining questions after reading this section is first what I can do to to have a role in the healing process, which Howard states is possible. I would also like to learn more about how to work through stereotypes, because I beleive that they are the food that I feed that crazy uncle. And I’m done nurturing him.

Monday, November 14, 2011

White Dominance and the Weight of the West

       The chapter of this book mainly addressed the concept of White dominance. It is definitely a sensitive subject because it often brings up guilt, shame and pain from those who are a member of White culture. The minute I saw that topic, I became uneasy and my internal monologue began: “No, I don’t want to read about this. I hate my culture for this, for slavery, racism and discrimination. How will this help me relate to my students?” Like Howard suggests in the text, I felt more blamed than enlightened.


Yet I can not move forward without addressing this issue of dominance, embedded in history. To understand my student’s cultural history, I must wrestle with the root causes and the dynamics of dominance. Howard lays out the essence of the Social Dominance theory on page 35 of the book; that humans are predisposed to have social hierarchies where those with authority “on top” and those with negative perceptions “on bottom.” Most types of social oppression are in connection to these hierarchies, where males predominantly are at the very top. These hierarchies are maintained by individual and institutional discrimination. 

Howard tells us that it is essentially a question of perspective. It is your perspective on a matter that affects your relationship with people. He suggests that one of the first steps in becoming a culturally competent individual is to engage with other people groups that are different than your own. When reading this, I was reminded of my studies of worldview. Worldview is defined as our philosophy of life.  Experiencing new people, perspectives and worldview only strengthens our thoughts and cultural identities. 


When we do this, we grow into a more culturally competent educators. It begins with this step, this clashing of worldview, we hear people's stories. This helps and challenges us as we begin to hear to stories. As educators, Howard suggests that we must understand how the educational system was used as a tool for dominance and "white-washing" people. It is not an easy to hear and not easy to wrestle with. I leave you now with a quote from Howard that we must understand.  

“We are a world in need of healing, but healing can begin only when we acknowledge the depth of the pain (p 51-52).” 

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Week One: White Man Dancing

This week's reading was full of great introduction to the text, visual imagery and personal connection, as to how the author grow to become a white man in his fifties writing a book for white educators working in multiracial classrooms called "We Can't Teach What We Don't Know."


In the introduction he discusses the actual importance of this task and the mission of his book: "the necessity to prepare a predominantly White teaching force to work, effectively with an increasingly diverse student population (pg. 1)." It is so important for teachers to become culturally competent, with not only the cultures represented in their classroom, but with their own. This "reeducation" of the educator is the way that he suggest addressing the issues in the classroom that have to do with race or ethnicity. You may ask yourself, what are these issues? Well, NCLB required information has shown us that there is a race-based academic achievement gap in the school's across the nation. And because so much of the definition of success in our country is related to academic achievement, this creates a problem.


The answer to this problem lies in starting with yourself. That is the essential point from the first chapter. Howard describes his youth as a time where his race was so normal is was a non-issue. He began to describe how slowly, "in the simple act of coming together to share a good time, we broke through the wall, creating one small crack in the artificial barrier of racial isolation (p. 14)." That's essentially how the transformation into a culturally competent person begins, by having experiences and relationships outside your cultural bubble.


I personally identify with how this book begins, as someone who has struggled with elements of racial and cultural identity. I am classified as White, ethnically. However, my mother was born and raised in Spain. She was racially classified as white but often told us the her blood was all Espana. She raised us with cultural awareness, and as a child, it's almost a non-issue. But as I grew older, I became more aware that because I had white skin, there was a history that it came with. I wanted to dissociate myself in every way. I was angry. This alone shows me that there is validity in this books's mission. There is a journey that I must go on to grow in my own cultural understanding. So, let it begin.